Skip to content

What the HOAI does not govern

📐 Article

By , construction economist

Information verified on 6 min read

What you will learn Why the HOAI is price law rather than a law of obligations, which central questions it leaves open, why the service profiles nonetheless serve as the practical measure, and what follows for the design contract.

The HOAI is a narrow instrument with a clearly bounded subject: it governs the calculation of remuneration. Everything else it does not govern.

That observation sounds academic and is the source of a substantial share of all misunderstandings between designers and clients. Anyone treating the regulation as service law looks there for answers it does not contain.

Price law, not a law of obligations

The ordinance describes services in order to make fees calculable. It does not describe them in order to create duties.

That is more than a nuance. The services listed in the profiles are not a schedule of contractual obligations. They are not required on every project, and conversely the contractual result owed may demand services not listed there.

What is owed follows from the contract and from general contract law. What is owed there is a result, not the working through of a catalogue.

In practice: a designer who has performed all basic services of a phase has not necessarily discharged their contractual duty where the result owed is absent. And conversely a service may be dispensable although it appears in the catalogue.

The central open questions

Question Where it is governed
What result is owed contract and general contract law
Who is liable for design errors general contract law, contract
When the contract may be terminated general contract law, contract
What periods apply to defect claims general contract law, contract
Who holds copyright copyright law
What insurance is required state professional law, contract
Who may submit building applications state building codes
How public procurement proceeds procurement law

The last two rows carry particular consequence, because they concern state law. Entitlement to submit building applications and the requirements for construction supervision under the state building codes differ between the federal states, and the HOAI says nothing about them.

The state law system is covered in the subject area on German building regulations, and procurement questions in the subject area on tendering under the VOB. The procurement questions are covered in the subject area on tendering under the VOB.

Why the service profiles still serve as the measure

A contradiction needs resolving here: the service profiles are not a schedule of obligations, and yet they serve almost universally in practice as the description of scope. The resolution lies in the legal nature of the reference.

The reason is pragmatic. They are the only normed catalogue of what a design phase customarily comprises. No other body of rules describes the course of a design process with comparable system.

A widespread and workable contractual practice follows: scope is described through the work phases, with departures expressly named. That is permissible and sensible.

What must be observed is only the legal nature of the reference. Where the service profiles are incorporated, they become contract terms by agreement, not by force of the ordinance. They then apply as far as the agreement reaches, and they are supplemented by the result owed.

Their significance has grown since 2021

One effect of the reform is rarely named: the significance of the service profiles has grown while that of the fee tables has fallen. The two movements condition one another.

While the rates bound the parties, disputes were mostly about level. Today the level is freely negotiable, and the dispute shifts to what is owed for the amount agreed.

The service profiles have thereby moved from a by-product of fee calculation to the most important normative reference point of the contract, although legally they remain no schedule of obligations. That tension has to be borne and named in the contract.

What follows for the contract

Four points need regulating because the HOAI leaves them open. The fourth is most often skipped and is economically the most significant on long construction periods.

Point to regulate What it must settle
The result owed not only the work phases but the objective: which building, to what quality, within what cost frame, by when
Departures from the service profile which basic services fall away, which additional services are added
Allocation of responsibility particularly where services are shifted, such as detailed design to the contractor
Dates the HOAI knows no deadlines for performance; without a contractual provision the general law of works contracts applies

The reason lies in how site supervision is framed: its effort grows with the construction period while the fee basis stays fixed. Without a provision on dates the designer carries that imbalance alone.

A special case: cross-border commissions

Until the end of 2020 the HOAI applied only to service providers established in Germany whose services were performed from within Germany. For contracts from 1 January 2021 this restriction has fallen away.

Version of the HOAI Territorial restriction
2009 and 2013 versions (contracts up to 31 December 2020) only service providers established in Germany, services provided from within Germany
current version (contracts from 1 January 2021) no restriction by place of establishment or place of performance

Since 2021 the place where a practice is established no longer decides whether the HOAI applies. It can, however, still determine which contract law applies: absent a choice of law, a design contract is as a rule governed by the law of the state in which the practice is established.

Nor has the place from which the services are performed been a criterion of the scope since 2021. For cross-border commissions what matters above all is which law governs the contract and what it agrees on the fee. Both should therefore be settled expressly in the contract.

This article reflects the position of the rules and case law at the date of checking and serves professional orientation. It does not constitute legal advice and does not replace assessment of the individual case.

Frequently asked questions

The content of the contract and liability, because it is price law and not service law. The article names the open questions.

Because practice uses them as a description of the service owed. They act through the contract.

Yes, since 2021 more is settled through the contract. The description of services gains weight accordingly.

Scope, remuneration and adjustments belong in express provisions. The article names the points.

← HOAI work phases: fees and service profiles for architects