Blog

The contract documents of the progetto esecutivo

📐 Topic6 min read

ResourcesBill of quantities › The contract documents of the progetto esecutivo

Some deliverables of the progetto esecutivo, the Italian detailed design, serve a descriptive purpose. Others serve a contractual one: they govern the relationship between client and contractor and are intended to be relied upon in the event of dispute. The computo metrico estimativo sits at the boundary between the two categories, and its robustness depends on consistency with the documents beside it.

The capitolato speciale d'appalto

This is the deliverable that sets the technical and administrative rules of execution, comparable to a combined specification and conditions of contract. Under article 32 of Annex I.7 to the public contracts code the capitolato speciale is divided into two parts: the first contains the description of the works, the second the technical requirements. In practice the administrative part governs the contract amount, the time periods, liquidated damages and the rules for valuation and payment, while the technical part describes materials, execution methods and acceptance criteria.

The link with the bill of quantities runs both ways. Every measured item must find in the technical part the description of the work that justifies it, and every onerous technical requirement must find in the bill an item that values it. Discrepancies between the two documents are the leading source of requests for new rates during construction.

The capitolato speciale is attached to the draft contract. For complex works it must also include a site inspection plan, setting out the programme of checks to be carried out at the various stages.

The draft contract

The schema di contratto contains the clauses governing the relationship between the authority and the contractor in relation to the characteristics of the works. It is the document into which the other contract deliverables are incorporated by reference, and in which it is established whether the consideration is fixed as a lump sum or measured. That choice conditions how the bill of quantities will be used during construction, and is therefore covered in a dedicated page.

The elenco dei prezzi unitari

Article 31 of Annex I.7 places the elenco dei prezzi unitari, the schedule of unit rates, alongside the bill of quantities and the cost framework. The schedule collects the rates applied in the bill, including items determined by analysis, and becomes the reference for valuing changes: variations are valued by applying the rates in the schedule attached to the contract, reduced by the discount percentage offered at tender.

Connected to the same article is the labour incidence schedule, which aggregates in tabular form the labour component attributable to the various parts of the works. It is often treated as a formality, whereas in practice it makes the estimate of labour costs verifiable, and in public works those costs must be stated separately in the tender documents.

The capitolato informativo

Legislative Decree 209 of 2024, the corrective decree to the code, introduced article 32-ter of Annex I.7, devoted to the capitolato informativo, the employer's information requirements document. It defines the general and specific information requirements needed for digital management of the project, and its importance grows as the use of digital information management methods and tools spreads. Where the bill of quantities is derived from a model, the capitolato informativo is the document that establishes the level of detail and reliability at which quantities must be extractable.

Hierarchy and consistency between documents

A logical sequence of checks is worth keeping in mind during preparation, because each link feeds the next. An error upstream propagates through the whole chain.

Step Check
Drawings to bill Every quantity is traceable to a drawing through an explicit calculation
Technical specification to bill Every onerous requirement has a corresponding item
Bill to schedule of rates All rates applied appear in the schedule, including analyses
Bill to cost framework The works amount shown in the cost framework derives from the bill
Bill to programme Measured works are sequenced in a compatible way
Safety plan to bill Safety costs are quantified and kept separate

This cross-check is precisely what the design validation procedure sets out to test, and carrying it out during preparation appreciably reduces the observations raised at verification stage. Carrying it out during preparation markedly reduces the findings.

The most frequent inconsistencies

Certain discrepancies between deliverables recur with regularity, and knowing them in advance is the cheapest way of preventing them. Knowing them in advance is the cheapest way to prevent them.

A requirement without an item is the most common case: the specification imposes an operation or a material characteristic for which the bill contains no corresponding item. At tender stage the bidder either sees it and prices it into the discount, or does not see it and claims it during construction.

An item without a requirement is the mirror case: the bill values an operation the specification does not describe. There is then no acceptance criterion, and site verification becomes discretionary.

Misaligned units of measurement between bill, schedule of rates and specification produce valuations that cannot be compared and force the estimate to be reconstructed after the fact. The estimate must then be rebuilt item by item.

Safety costs merged into the works items deprive the non discountable component of the protection the law affords it, with a direct effect on the amount recognised to the contractor. The effect shows directly in the tender amount.

A programme incompatible with the measured works, finally, makes the forecast of interim valuations unreliable and with it the project's cash flow profile. The cash profile of the operation is distorted as a result.

Note: the legislative references in this page relate to Italy and are current as at the date of publication. Public procurement rules change frequently, and the version in force should be checked before any operational use.

Frequently asked questions

The special specification, the draft contract, the schedule of unit rates and the information specification. Each has a distinct function.

To set out the technical and administrative requirements of the contract. It is the document that turns the design into contractual obligations.

By applying the hierarchy set in the tender documents, which must be explicit. Without it, the inconsistency is argued over, with the costs that follow.

Those between drawings, bill of quantities and specification, often on quantities and finishes. They are prevented by a cross-check before publication.

The computo metrico estimativo: from preparation to price books and specification